The title of this post is a bit of a misnomer. In fact, it might have been titled How to Do Nothing and Get Results, but I had a good experience with a student this week and I want to share it. Maybe in writing it down, I will get some insight into how to replicate the results and reach more students.
I have a student, we'll call her Ella, who has been really getting on my nerves this week. At the beginning of the year, I recognized how smart she was, only to realize that she seemed to care little about school and certainly wanted nothing to do with my class. For the past week or two, she has not listened to a single word I have said, and when I call her out or ask her to stop talking, she simply snaps at me. The exchange goes something like this:
"Ella, could you please focus on the lesson?"
"Why? This class is boring. Nobody even understands what you are talking about."
"Ok, well we need to learn this, so if you can't focus and stop being distracting, I'm going to have to ask you to leave the classroom."
"Thank God!" [here, she gathers her stuff and saunters out of the room]
I was not feeling great about the whole thing. While I complained to everyone who would listen about how frustrating this student was, I also blamed myself. Maybe my class really wasn't engaging enough. Maybe I wasn't putting enough time into creating interesting motivation and buy-in from my students. Maybe I wasn't giving Ella enough attention - I was losing her and not helping her catch up, so she was discouraged and lashing out to make up for it.
With all these thought running around in my head, I tried to stay positive. I focused on my lessons and tried to give Ella more one-on-one attention. Even though she didn't really respond to my efforts, I kept trying and didn't let on how discouraged I was. Still, it seemed to be having little effect.
Then today, something miraculous happened. Perhaps outside pressure had something to do with it, but for whatever reason, Ella decided she was going to stay with me during lunch to go over a quiz we had just taken. When away from her classmates, Ella is an intelligent and respectful girl. She closed the door so that she wouldn't be distracted and sat with me for the entire period until she really understood the material she had so roundly discarded the previous days. She redid her quiz and ended up with almost a perfect score.
I took the opportunity of having her captive to talk to her not only about the material, but about what had been going on in class behaviorally. I apologized for not giving her enough attention and she in turn laughed at her own "mood swings" and said she would try harder to focus. I also asked her to give me suggestions about how to make the class more interesting, acknowledging that the Earth Science material can sometimes feel a bit dry. Although she didn't have ready suggestions for me, I fully expect to hear back from her. If I don't, I will make sure to ask.
Hopefully by giving her a sense of ownership, I can get her to become a productive member of the class and she can serve as a model for other difficult students. She is popular and charismatic, so I hope others will be inspired to follow her lead.